It's a Musical Thing ....
via Xark!
UPDATE: Alan Watts Theater
Exercising my freedom to; Guaranteed by my freedom from.
Author discusses blog posting that links military service, serial killers
Well, not exactly. The current post has been changed compared to the deleted post. For example, here's what the first few paragraphs might look like if the original post was modified using Rebecca Blood's guidelines:The blogosphere is going crazy today over a posting at the liberal Daily Kos entitled: "Killitary: How America's Armed Forces Create Serial Killers and Mass Murderers."
The posting was removed from the blog at some point after it was published Thursday night. (It also appears to have been removed from the author's personal blog. Here's the cached version.)
A cached version of the Daily Kos posting is available through Google....
Update at 1:40 p.m. ET: The posting is back on the In Cold Blog.
Friday, July 20, 2007The rest of the post is similar to the deleted one until the conclusion, where a sentence and two paragraphs have also been added:KILLITARY:
How America's Armed Forces Create Serial Killers and Mass MurderersAre America's Armed Forces Creating Serial Killers and Mass Murderers?[Update: I decided to repost this after being excoriated by both left- and right-wing blogs. After speaking with various military personnel who read this post they assured me that it is very obvious and clear what I was getting at. The military trains people to kill and some of our men and women return home and don't receive the proper care to deal with the horrors of war or even the intensity of training. Not a single one of them thought I was trying to smear the soldiers or call them serial killers. They thanked me for pointing out a serious problem that gets overlooked by the military and needs to be dealt with.]
[Update: This article in no way is meant to suggest that all mil[i]tary members will become serial killers or mass murderers. It does point out a serious problem with what is happening in our armed forces and seeks a solution to help the brave men and women on their return back home.]
According to the July 30, 2007 issue of The Nation magazine, damning photos of a U.S. Soldier using a spoon to literally scoop out the brains of a dead Iraqi and pretending to eat the gray matter were recently acquired.Of course, everyone is appropriately appalled and make all claims of disgust and finger-wagging. Research shows, however, that such unacceptable behavior happens more often than the United States military wants you to know.
When it comes to training killing machines, the military really does create "an Army of one."
The list of serial killers and mass murderersborne fromwho have spent time in the military is astounding....
The author, Corey Mitchell, also told USA Today's On Deadline blog:Here Are a Few More Not So Good Men:All served in the military. All went on to become serial killers, mass murderers, or assassins. [Update: Others were already killers who became even worse after their time in the service.
Of course, the number who become serial killers or mass murderers compared to the rest of the hundreds of thousands of troops who do not is minimal. But isn't one serial killer one too many?]
John Allen Muhammad ("The Beltway Sniper"), Arthur Shawcross, Lee Harvey Oswald, Randy Kraft, Dennis Rader ("BTK"), Howard Unruh, Robert Lee Yates, Gary Heidnik, Charles Cullen, Charles Ng, Henry Louis Wallace, Julian Knight, Courtney Mathews & David Housler, Daryl Keith Holton, Wayne Adam Ford, Richard Marc Evonitz, etc.This list is by no means comprehensive and does not include military personnel who murdered their families, loved ones, or friends upon their return from training to kill or war.
[Update: This article in no way is meant to suggest that all mil[i]tary members will become serial killers or mass murderers. It does point out a serious problem with what is happening in our armed forces and seeks a solution to help the brave men and women on their return back home.]
Mitchell says he may decide to republish the piece on his blog, but is weighing the effect of all the negative attention on his wife, who works on a military base, and their young daughter. "I have to weigh my family's stress level versus how necessary is it to have that piece up," he writes in a follow-up e-mail.Apparently, Mitchell decided it was necessary ... with some modifications. The modifications came from being "excoriated by both left- and right-wing blogs."
Yesterday, Armando Llorens at TalkLeft posted an embarrassing (for him) list of CPAC sponsors to counter Dean Barnett and the JetBlue/YearlyKos sponsorship controversy.
The post was also duplicated elsewhere (i.e. LeftWord).
Unfortunately, the CPAC he quoted from, and linked to, wasn't the intended Conservative Political Action Conference but instead the Center for Process Analytical Chemistry.
The entire post was subsequently deleted. I don't know how long the post was up at TalkLeft. The time stamp on the post was Tue Jul 17, 2007 at 11:38:57 AM EST. It seems Google cached it within 20 minutes of posting: retrieved on 17 Jul 2007 16:51:56 GMT.
I certainly understand why Armando would want to delete the post and - depending how long it had been up - why he thought he could (without anyone noticing?). This is NOT about embarrassing Armando.
It is a blogging ethics question. Links rot. Posts are deleted. Entire blogs disappear (I deleted my previous blog, took a year off and started over). So what? Quoted passages or entire posts of now nonexistent blog posts or entire blogs may continue to exist elsewhere on the 'net with the corresponding reference link broken. Again, so what?
What really was lost when Armando deleted that post besides his own potential embarrassment and misleading his readers? Should he have put an update on the post with a retraction instead? Would you? Why?
What do you think about bloggers deleting posts? What would you think if it was a news organization or another publication that deleted an online story without notice or explanation?
As a discussion starting point, Rebecca Blood wrote in 2002:
4. Write each entry as if it could not be changed; add to, but do not rewrite or delete, any entry.Your thoughts?Post deliberately. If you invest each entry with intent, you will ensure your personal and professional integrity.
Changing or deleting entries destroys the integrity of the network. The Web is designed to be connected; indeed, the weblog permalink is an invitation for others to link. Anyone who comments on or cites a document on the Web relies on that document (or entry) to remain unchanged. A prominent addendum is the preferred way to correct any information anywhere on the Web. If an addendum is impractical, as in the case of an essay that contains numerous inaccuracies, changes must be noted with the date and a brief description of the nature of the change.
If you think this is overly scrupulous, consider the case of the writer who points to an online document in support of an assertion. If this document changes or disappears — and especially if the change is not noted — her argument may be rendered nonsensical. Books do not change; journals are static. On paper, new versions are always denoted as such.
The network of shared knowledge we are building will never be more than a novelty unless we protect its integrity by creating permanent records of our publications. The network benefits when even entries that are rendered irrelevant by changing circumstance are left as a historical record. As an example: A weblogger complains about inaccuracies in an online article; the writer corrects those inaccuracies (and notes them!); the weblogger's entry is therefore meaningless — or is it? Deleting the entry somehow asserts that the whole incident simply didn't happen — but it did. The record is more accurate and history is better served if the weblogger notes beneath the original entry that the writer has made the corrections and the article is now, to the weblogger's knowledge, accurate.
History can be rewritten, but it cannot be undone. Changing or deleting words is possible on the Web, but possibility does not always make good policy. Think before you publish and stand behind what you write. If you later decide you were wrong about something, make a note of it and move on.
I make a point never to post anything I am not willing to stand behind even if I later disagree. I work to be thoughtful and accurate, no matter how angry or excited I am about a particular topic. If I change my opinion in a day or two, I just note the change. If I need to apologize for something I've said, I do so.
If you discover that you have posted erroneous information, you must note this publicly on your weblog. Deleting the offending entry will do nothing to correct the misinformation your readers have already absorbed. Taking the additional step of adding a correction to the original entry will ensure that Google broadcasts accurate information into the future.
The only exception to this rule is when you inadvertently reveal personal information about someone else. If you discover that you have violated a confidence or made an acquaintance uncomfortable by mentioning him, it is only fair to remove the offending entry altogether, but note that you have done so.
Over at Assignment Zero there is a discussion about the changing role of experts in the "new" media ecosystem:
In a traditional model the expert is regarded as the keeper of information, ideas and knowledge. In a dispersed network, the expert has some serious competition. If experts aren't the sole source for valuable information anymore, what makes them an expert? How do their roles change?Robin Sloan (of EPIC 2014 fame) comments:
Besides being keepers of information, experts are also the people we go to for predictions, for guidance -- especially in traditional journalism. A standard trend piece goes like this: You interview some representative "data points," then go to an expert to ask what it all means, how it's going to play out. In fact, I feel like I see experts doing much MORE prediction than education in the media -- especially in domains like politics, technology, etc.I prefer to think of expertise in terms of a Data, Information, Knowledge, Wisdom (DIKW) hierarchy. I think this would also be helpful for reporters to understand what their readers perceive concerning the quality and quantity of "truth" in their news. DIKW comes from the study of Knowledge Management and Information Science. A paper by Nikhil Sharma discusses the origin of the Data Information Knowledge Wisdom Hierarchy. I would also recommend a paper by Gene Bellinger, Durval Castro, and Anthony Mills which discusses the role 'understanding' plays in Russell Ackoff's original version of the DIKW hierarchy.
Unfortunately, there is evidence that experts are no good at making predictions.
I suspected at the outset that we as a society would be better off if we held experts -- be they pundits in the public arena or intelligence analysts behind the scenes -- systematically accountable to standards of evidence that command broad assent across the spectrum of reasonable opinion. Subsequent findings from this project -- as well as events over the last twenty tears -- have reinforced my suspicion that there is something wrong with existing mechanisms for getting to the truth both in the media-driven marketplace of ideas and in the top-secret world of intelligence analysis.Everybody’s An Expert
No one is paying you for your gratuitous opinions about other people, but the experts are being paid, and Tetlock claims that the better known and more frequently quoted they are, the less reliable their guesses about the future are likely to be. The accuracy of an expert’s predictions actually has an inverse relationship to his or her self-confidence, renown, and, beyond a certain point, depth of knowledge. People who follow current events by reading the papers and newsmagazines regularly can guess what is likely to happen about as accurately as the specialists whom the papers quote. Our system of expertise is completely inside out: it rewards bad judgments over good ones.
Plato: Symposium
Suppose Hephaestus, with his instruments, to come to the pair who are lying side, by side and to say to them, "What do you people want of one another?" they would be unable to explain. And suppose further, that when he saw their perplexity he said: "Do you desire to be wholly one; always day and night to be in one another's company? for if this is what you desire, I am ready to melt you into one and let you grow together, so that being two you shall become one, and while you live a common life as if you were a single man, and after your death in the world below still be one departed soul instead of two-I ask whether this is what you lovingly desire, and whether you are satisfied to attain this?"-there is not a man of them who when he heard the proposal would deny or would not acknowledge that this meeting and melting into one another, this becoming one instead of two, was the very expression of his ancient need. And the reason is that human nature was originally one and we were a whole, and the desire and pursuit of the whole is called love. [link added]
If a journalist writes a column telling you a couple of journalism professors found that journalists test well on ethics ... well, would you be skeptical?
I was.
The column, by Peter Johnson, appears in the Life section of USA Today and reads pretty much like the professors' press release. The article is not skeptical of the findings and only the professors and Tom Rosenstiel are quoted.
Would it surprise you to find out that a survey similar to the one being reported by Johnson, with similar results, was done in 1995? Surprised me, especially since it's not mentioned by Johnson or Rosenstiel. The day before Johnson's USA Today column was published, Erica Rogers wrote in the Daily Nebraskan:
The "Defining Issues Test," written by Dr. James Rest and based on Lawrence Kohlberg's theoretical "stages of moral development" has been given to 20,000 people during the previous 30 years. In 1995 Journalists scored just below theologians and physicians - professions considered to be highly ethical.Hey! That's the same test this survey used, except Professor Wilkins says it's been given to 30,000 professionals over the past 30 years:
Lee Wilkins, journalism professor in the Missouri School of Journalism, and Renita Coleman of Louisiana State University, administered the Defining Issues Test, which measures moral development, to 249 reporters from print and broadcast newsrooms from across the country. The test, according to Wilkins, has been given to at least 30,000 professionals over the past 30 years; however, it had never been given to journalists.Huh. Never been given to journalists according to Wilkins. Journalists scored just below theologians and physicians in 1995, according to Rogers. Maybe the 1995 date is a typo in Rogers' column? Maybe the number tested over the past 30 years is wrong, too. No worries - give or take 10,000 - that's what I always say.
Tom Rosenstiel of Columbia University's Project for Excellence in Journalism says the findings echo what the Pew Research Center found in a survey of journalists in 1999.Really? Here is the 1999 Pew report. And here is a summary of the recent survey's findings:
... a new book-length study by a University of Missouri-Columbia researcher found that journalism is one of the most morally developed professions in the country, ranking behind only seminarians, physicians and medical students. ...I couldn't find in the 1999 Pew report where journalists "scored" high on morals or ethics, or that the journalistic profession is "one of the most morally developed professions in the country" as stated in this recent survey's summary. Instead, the Pew report surveyed journalists' opinions about their own professional principles, values and organization's ethics programs, but does that qualify as an echo of this survey's findings?
They found that journalists scored fourth highest among professionals tested, above dental students, nurses, graduate students, undergraduate college students, veterinary students and adults in general. No significant differences were found between various groups of journalists, including men and women, or broadcast and print reporters. Journalists who did civic journalism or investigative reporting scored significantly higher those who did not. When ethical problems were professionally focused, journalists performed even better.
Values and the Press: Journalists at national and local news organizations are notably different from the general public in their ideology and attitudes toward political and social issues. Most national and local journalists, as well as a plurality of Americans (41%), describe themselves as political moderates. But news people especially national journalists are more liberal, and far less conservative, than the general public.That's not the same, is it? Being more liberal and being more ethical?
Previous research has consistently shown that those on the political Right tend to prefer or use conventional or Stage 4 moral reasoning, while those on the political Left prefer principled or Stage 5 reasoning (cf. Kohlberg, 1976).And this 2004 abstract:
Liberals and moderates scored significantly higher than conservatives did in postconventional reasoning on the DIT-2 but not on the SSMS. These results support findings of previous research demonstrating the political dimensions of the DIT, as well as reinforce the multidimensional nature of moral behavior and moral judgment.Now there's an echo! Journalists are more liberal. Liberals score higher on the Defining Issues Test (DIT). Correlation established!
"Most of them got into the business out of a sense that journalism helps democracy work and that they are helping their fellow citizens," [Rosenstiel] says.I've read a fair share of moral philosophers, but it wasn't until Rosenstiel's quote, at the end of Johnson's column, that I got an inkling of which moral philosophy the DIT uses. Rosenstiel's quote equates "serve the public interest" and "sense of public mission" with being more morally developed.
"Journalists get in this business out of an overriding sense of wanting to serve the public interest. They work bad hours, are grossly underpaid, they are derided by other media in Hollywood and increasingly distrusted by the public.
"So if you're not motivated by a sense of public mission, there's not a lot of reason to do it."
In the 1970s, a Harvard researcher named Lawrence Kohlberg created a six-stage model of moral development based on the work of Jean Piaget. The model emerged out of Kohlberg's extensive interviews with children and adults, which showed, according to the researcher, that there were three levels of moral development, each consisting of two stages. The first level, called Preconventional, is self-focused. At stage one, individuals have a punishment and obedience orientation in which they understand right as being obedience to an authority figure and avoidance of punishment. At stage two, individuals see right actions as those which meet their own needs. At this stage, as with the first, there is little regard for others.The DIT is not without its skeptics or challengers. I found this from Cabot's paper telling:
The second level, called Conventional, consists of stages three and four. At stage three, the individual has an "interpersonal concordance" orientation, where the right choice is one that results in social approval. At stage four, individuals have a "law and order" orientation, where right and wrong are tied directly to formal rules and laws.
At the third level, called Postconventional, individuals are categorized into what Kohlberg calls the "principle" stages. At stage five, individuals have a "social contract" orientation, where a moral right is based on social principles behind the laws. Finally, at stage six, individuals have a "universal ethical principle" orientation, where they adhere to universally valued principles (e.g., justice for all).
Another challenge to the DIT is the questionable relationship between one's score on a moral reasoning test and how one would actually behave in a real-life ethical dilemma: When people come across moral conflicts in their lives the question they are faced with is: "what should I do?" which is different to "what should one do?".[sic] Reasoning in real-life situations involves decisions which are much more practical, self-serving and less rational than the reasoning of hypothetical characters. (Haviv & Leman, p. 124)Maybe testing well on the DIT doesn't tell us much, after all. Johnson might have told us about these "challenges".
Copyright ©
All rights reserved
Creative Commons License
| Solar X-rays: Geomagnetic Field: |
The views and opinions expressed on this web site are those of the author(s) and do not reflect the views of my employer, the official policy or position of any unit, the Department of the Army, Department of Defense, or the U.S. Government
Copyright © All rights reserved
Creative Commons License